Loading
Loading
  1. Home
  2. Teaching and Learning Activities and Resources
  3.     > Chapter 1
  4.     > Chapter 2
  5.     > Chapter 3
  6.     > Chapter 4
  7.     > Chapter 5
  8.     > Chapter 6
  9.     > Chapter 7 
  10. Video Library
  11.     > Chapter 2
  12.     > Chapter 3
  13.     > Chapter 4 
  14.     > Chapter 5
  15.     > Chapter 6
  16. About this Book
  17.     > About the authors
  18.     > About the critical commentary authors
  19. Sample Materials
  20.     > Excerpt 
  21. Tour of the Book
  22.     > Selected glossary

Chapter 2

Childhood Constructions in Museums of Childhood

Check out the National Childhood Collection, now with the Victoria & Albert Museum of Childhood. Considering photographs of the items in the collection …  


  1. What social constructions of childhood are put forward? Do you notice differences over time or contexts (and, if so, what are these)?
  2. Can you find examples of items, which can be critiqued according to decolonization theories? What would the critiques be?
  3. Can you find examples of items that demonstrate childism or adultism? In what ways? 

You can filter the collection by categories – children’s clothes and dolls & toys are particularly useful filters for the above questions.  


Do you have a local museum of childhood or have access to other museums online? Examples include: 


ü The Strong National Museum of Play in Rochester New York 

ü Le Musee des Enfants in Brussels, Belgium 

ü CosmoCaixa in Barcelona, Spain 

ü Junibacken in Stockholm, Sweden 

ü Papalote Museo del Nino in Mexico City, Mexico 

ü Seoul Children's Museum in Seoul, South Korea 


You may find it interesting to explore these further. Are they museums of or for children (or both)? If you visit the museums, how do children of different ages and backgrounds interact with the museum’s collections and space? What do the answers to these questions tell you about social constructions of childhood, decolonization, childism/adultism and generational order 

 

Children and Young People's Views of Adults

The activism of children and young people has recently captured global attention.  

Have a look and/or listen to examples you can find on the internet, or other sources, of child and youth activists addressing largely adult audiences. Examples are: 


ü Malala Yousafzai addressing the United Nations in 2013 on education https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3rNhZu3ttIU 

ü Greta Thunberg’s speech to world leaders at the 2019 UN climate action summit in New York https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u9KxE4Kv9A8 

ü World Vision Young Leaders Addressing Violence Against Children – webinar https://youtu.be/0BYImjckUxQ 


In these examples:  


  1. What social constructions of childhood do the activists put forward?
  2. What social constructions of adulthood do the activists put forward?
  3. What are the implications of these constructions for the problem being discussed, and for the potential solutions in policy or practice?


Exploring Children's Agency 

Karina Padilla Malca undertook her PhD research in a flood-prone area in Amazonian Peru. Her study explored the lived citizenship of early childhood in this context, collecting data over 9 months using ethnographic research methods.  

 

Below are some excerpts from her fieldwork, where children found ways and places to play within their neighbourhood.  

 

(To note that all children’s names are pseudonyms and their consent for these images to be used were given by them and their parents.) 


Consider these examples from the perspectives of children’s agency: 


  1. Do you think children were expressing their agency? If so, in what ways? Consider in light of different definitions of agency you can find in Chapter 2: Foundations of Childhood Studies.
  2. If you consider Klocker’s distinctions between ‘thick’ and ‘thin’ agency1  … in what ways was children’s agency thickened or thinned in these contexts? What changes might have thickened their agency?
  3. Are there aspects where children are expressing ‘ambiguous agency’, when children’s agency threatens or goes against existing moral and social orders (Bordonaro and Payne 2012)? What are the practical and conceptual implications of this? 

One picture (see below) shows children playing under an empty house, in the transition period for the flooding. The water was increasing and it was difficult to move on the street.


                                      
















Karina further explains the photograph:         

    

“Children in this photograph were sitting in the motorcar talking and drawing. The motorcar belonged to a neighbour who could not use the vehicle to go to work because of the mud; therefore, the owner used the ground under the house as a garage. … [The] children’s gathering finished when the owner of the motorcar yelled at us to leave the place. The children laughed and invited me to go to Jimena’s house.”  


Another picture shows children playing on the first floor of an empty house during the flood season:  

                                                                                                                                               

















Karina further describes the photograph’s context: 


“…[they were] on the first floor because the ground floor was covered by water. As it was an empty house, it did not have bridge to access it. The day I took the photograph, the children showed me how they climbed to the place from Jimena’s house who lived next to it.” 


You may want to read more about Karina’s analysis – her PhD is available in the Edinburgh Research Archive ‘Lived citizenship in early childhood in a flood-prone area in Amazonian Peru’.  



1

 … ‘thin’ agency refers to decisions and everyday actions that are carried out within highly restrictive contexts, characterized by few viable alternatives. ‘Thick’ agency is having the latitude to act within a broad range of options. It is possible for a person’s agency to be ‘thickened’ or ‘thinned’ over time and space, and across their various relationships. Structures, contexts, and relationships can act as ‘thinners’ or ‘thickeners’ of individual’s agency, by constraining or expanding their range of viable choices. (2007: 85)

 Klocker, N. (2007), ‘An example of “thin” agency: Child domestic workers in Tanzania’, in R. Panelli, S. Punch and E. Robson (eds), Global Perspectives on Rural Childhood and Youth, 83-94, New York: Routledge.