Foundations of Education 2nd Edition - Ch3 Lesson Plan 1
Skip to main content
Loading
Loading

.

  1. Home
  2. Chapter 1
  3.     > Lesson Plan 1 (Historical)
  4.     > Lesson Plan 2 (Contemporary)
  5.     > Slide Deck
  6.     > Self-Assessment
  7.     > Glossary
  8. Chapter 2
  9.     > Lesson Plan 1 (Historical)
  10.     > Lesson Plan 2 (Contemporary)
  11.     > Slide Deck
  12.     > Self-Assessment
  13.     > Glossary
  14. Chapter 3
  15.     > Lesson Plan 1 (Historical)
  16.     > Lesson Plan 2 (Contemporary)
  17.     > Slide Deck
  18.     > Self-Assessment
  19.     > Glossary
  20. Chapter 4
  21.     > Lesson Plan 1 (Historical)
  22.     > Lesson Plan 2 (Contemporary)
  23.     > Slide Deck
  24.     > Self-Assessment
  25.     > Glossary
  26. Chapter 5
  27.     > Lesson Plan 1 (Historical)
  28.     > Lesson Plan 2 (Contemporary)
  29.     > Slide Deck
  30.     > Self-Assessment
  31.     > Glossary
  32. Chapter 6
  33.     > Lesson Plan 1 (Historical)
  34.     > Lesson Plan 2 (Contemporary)
  35.     > Slide Deck
  36.     > Self-Assessment
  37.     > Glossary
  38. Chapter 7
  39.     > Lesson Plan 1 (Historical)
  40.     > Lesson Plan 2 (Contemporary)
  41.     > Slide Deck
  42.     > Self-Assessment
  43.     > Glossary

This lesson plan is also available as a Word file here.

Chapter 3 Lesson Plan 1: Social Class and Education - Historical Perspectives

Course Level: Undergraduate and Graduate Education Studies

Estimated Time: 3-4 hours

Learning Objectives

By the end of this lesson, students will be able to:

  1. Trace the evolution of educational access and opportunity from colonial times through the mid-20th century 
  2. Analyze how social class shaped educational policy and practice across different historical periods
  3. Evaluate the "great equalizer" concept and assess its historical validity
  4. Connect historical patterns of educational inequality to contemporary issues
  5. Apply critical thinking to examine how ideologies like Social Darwinism influenced educational systems

Lesson Structure

Segment 1: Introduction and Colonial Foundations (30 minutes)

Opening Activity (10 minutes)

Anticipatory Set: Present students with this scenario:

"Imagine you are a parent in 1650s America. Your family's occupation, wealth, race, and location will determine your child's educational opportunities—or lack thereof. What factors might influence whether your child learns to read?"

  • Think-Pair-Share: Students reflect individually (2 min), discuss with partner (3 min), share with class (5 min)
  • Instructor captures responses on board, organizing by themes (class, race, geography, religion)

Mini-Lecture: Colonial Education and Class (15 minutes)

Key Points to Cover:

  • Virginia vs. Massachusetts models of education
  • Role of religion in early educational access
  • Sir William Berkeley's infamous quote about learning bringing "disobedience and heresy"
  • The Old Deluder Act of 1647 and its limitations
  • Educational hierarchy: petty schools → grammar schools → academies → colleges
  • Racial exclusions: laws against educating enslaved people

Teaching Strategy: Create a visual hierarchy showing the class-based educational ladder in colonial America

Primary Source Analysis (5 minutes)

Display and discuss Governor Berkeley's 1671 response:

"...there are no free schools nor printing... for learning brought disobedience, heresy, and sects into the world"

Guiding Questions:

  • What does this reveal about elite attitudes toward education?
  • How might this perspective have influenced policy?
  • What parallels (if any) exist in contemporary debates about education?

Segment 2: Early Republic Through Civil War (35 minutes)

Jigsaw Activity: Reform Movements and Reformers (20 minutes)

Setup: Divide class into expert groups (4-5 students each):

Group A: Benjamin Franklin and Practical Education

  • Focus: Franklin's Philadelphia Academy and "middling sorts"
  • Key quote: Harvard graduates "as great Blockheads as ever, only more proud"
  • Task: Identify Franklin's critique and his alternative vision

Group B: Rise of Common Schools

  • Focus: Industrialization, immigration, and social fears driving reform
  • Geographic spread from Massachusetts
  • Task: Explain the social conditions prompting common school movement

Group C: Horace Mann and the "Great Equalizer"

  • Focus: Mann's vision for universal education
  • His warnings about "overgrown wealth and desperate poverty"
  • Task: Analyze Mann's claims about education's equalizing power

Group D: Reality Check - The St. Louis Example

  • Focus: 1840-1880 data showing class-based dropout patterns
  • Father's occupation as predictor of educational attainment
  • Task: Compare promise vs. reality of educational opportunity

Jigsaw Process:

1.    Expert groups study their assigned topic (8 min)

2.    Students regroup into mixed teams with one expert from each original group (10 min)

3.    Each expert teaches their topic to new group (2-3 min each)

Whole Class Discussion (15 minutes)

Central Question: Was Horace Mann's "great equalizer" concept realistic or overly optimistic?

Discussion Protocol:

  • Chart "Evidence Supporting Mann" vs. "Evidence Challenging Mann"
  • Encourage students to draw from all four jigsaw topics
  • Connect to chapter's critique: "schools by themselves are not capable of solving deep-seated socioeconomic conditions"

Reflection Prompt: If education alone cannot equalize society, what is its appropriate role in addressing inequality?


Segment 3: Late 19th/Early 20th Century - Ideology and Industry (50 minutes)

Interactive Lecture: Social Darwinism and Its Educational Impact (15 minutes)

Lecture Structure:

1.    Context Setting (3 min)

o   Gilded Age wealth inequality

o   Rapid industrialization and immigration

o   Rise of "scientific" management

2.    Social Darwinism Explained (5 min)

o   Herbert Spencer's "survival of the fittest"

o   Application to social policy

o   Appeal to industrialists like Carnegie and Rockefeller

o   The heredity thesis and intelligence testing

3.    Educational Consequences (7 min)

o   Tracking and classification systems

o   Sterilization laws in 27 states (lasting until 1970s!)

o   Vocational education as workforce preparation

o   Control of school boards by wealthy classes (76% from proprietorial, professional, managerial occupations in 1920s)

Visual Aid: Timeline showing parallel tracks - wealth concentration, Social Darwinist ideas, and educational policies

Critical Analysis Activity (15 minutes)

Success Literature Analysis:

Present the "rags to riches" phenomenon of Horatio Alger stories and success manuals (1870-1910)

Small Group Task (8 minutes): Groups of 3-4 analyze this tension:

  • Success literature promoted: hard work, frugality, character, "self-made" individuals
  • Success literature rejected: social Darwinism's determinism AND higher education
  • Aimed at: middle-class respectability, not great wealth

Guiding Questions:

1.    How did success literature contradict Social Darwinism while still supporting the status quo?

2.    Why might this ideology appeal to struggling families?

3.    What modern equivalents exist today? (Consider motivational content, influencer culture, "hustle" mentality)

Class Share-Out (7 minutes): Each group shares one insight

"For Further Reflection" Integration

Assign as quick think-write (5 minutes):

"In what ways are the ideas reflected in success literature of the 19th century still present today?"

Students write individual responses, then 2-3 volunteers share with class


Break (10 minutes) 


    Segment 4: Depression Through Post-WWII (25 minutes)

    • Case Study: Great Depression's Impact on Schools (10 minutes)

      Presentation Format: Instructor presents key information with visual data

      Key Data Points:

      • GNP dropped from $85.9B to $47B (1929-1934)
      • Unemployment rose from 3.2% to 24.9%
      • School budgets slashed (Chicago couldn't pay teachers, winter 1932-33)
      • Yet high school enrollment increased and graduation rates nearly doubled

      Paradox to Explore: Why did students stay in school during the economic crisis?

      Student Responses: Solicit explanations (lack of jobs, New Deal programs like NYA and WPA, school as refuge)

      Primary Source: The "Elmtown" Study (8 minutes)

      Document Analysis:

      Share findings from 1930s midwestern town study showing:

      • Social behavior of students closely related to family class position
      • Class determined curriculum tracking (college prep vs. vocational)
      • Grading patterns favored upper-class students
      • Discipline disproportionately applied to lower-class students
      • Conclusion: "the class system is far more vital as a social force in our society than the American creed"

      Partner Discussion: To what degree might these findings still hold true if the study were repeated today?

      GI Bill and Middle Class Expansion (7 minutes)

      Brief Lecture with Discussion:

      The Promise:

      • $14.5 billion spent on veterans' education
      • 500,000 university degrees in 1949-50 (vs. 216,500 in 1939-40)
      • Many veterans were first in families to attend college
      • Stimulated middle class growth

      The Reality:

      • Race-neutral language, discriminatory practice
      • Black veterans blocked by segregation and discrimination
      • Exacerbated White-Black wealth and education disparities in the South

      Discussion Question: How does the GI Bill illustrate both education's potential and its limitations as an equalizer?


        Segment 5: Synthesis and Contemporary Connections (20 minutes)

        Timeline Creation Activity (12 minutes)

        Group Task: In teams of 4-5, create a visual timeline identifying:

        1.    Promises Made: Key moments when education was promoted as solution to inequality

        2.    Barriers Maintained: Policies/practices that reinforced class divisions

        3.    Persistent Patterns: What remained constant across eras?

        Materials: Large paper or digital collaboration tool

        Examples to Include:

        • Colonial exclusions → Common schools → Social Darwinism → Depression-era stratification → GI Bill

        Gallery Walk (8 minutes)

        • Teams post timelines around room
        • Students circulate, add sticky note observations/questions to other groups' work
        • Brief whole-class debrief: What patterns emerged across all timelines?

          Closing: Historical Lessons for Today (10 minutes)

          Reflection and Bridge to Contemporary Issues

          Instructor-Led Discussion:

          Synthesis Questions:

          1.    What historical patterns from this lesson help explain contemporary educational inequalities?

          2.    Which historical arguments about education and social class do we still hear today?

          3.    Based on this history, what should we be cautious about when evaluating current education reforms?

          Written Exit Ticket (5 minutes):

          Students respond to ONE of the following:

          A. Identify one historical moment that most surprised you and explain why it matters for understanding education today.

          B. The chapter notes that "schools by themselves are not capable of solving deep-seated socioeconomic conditions." Based on today's historical evidence, do you agree or disagree? What role CAN schools play?

          C. Choose one historical ideology or policy discussed today (Social Darwinism, common schools, vocational education, etc.). Trace its legacy to a contemporary educational practice or debate.

          Collection: Gather exit tickets as students leave (can inform next class discussion)



            Assessment Options:

            1.    Research Project: Find a historical school or educational institution from your region. Investigate: Who attended? Who was excluded? How was it funded? Present findings in a 5-minute presentation.

            2.    Comparative Analysis: Select one historical period covered today. Research one additional primary source from that era and write a 2-page analysis connecting it to the chapter's themes.

            3.    Multimedia Project: Create a podcast episode, video essay, or infographic explaining one historical concept (e.g., Social Darwinism, common school movement) and its educational legacy.


              Resources for Further Exploration

            • Jonathan Kozol, Savage Inequalities (connects historical to contemporary funding issues)
            • James Anderson, The Education of Blacks in the South (fills gaps in mainstream educational history)
            • David Tyack & Larry Cuban, Tinkering Toward Utopia (educational reform in historical perspective)